RSS

Pony Stories 142

28 May

Yeah, I got nothing to put here. Maybe inspiration will strike and I’ll change this to something interesting. Of course, if you are reading this, that did not happen. (Or did it?) Three more ponyfic review-type dealies below the break. Wait, just glanced over at the comments of InquisitorM’s post on White Space where Chris over at One Man’s Pony Ramblings is being ignored as a reviewer (truthfulness of statements in my intro paragraphs are not guaranteed). One, that is the site I see if he’s updated every day even though I know he only updates three times a week. And two, he could always stop doing the review thing now that he’s gotten the rest of us doing it and instead write more awesome stories like Wyrmlysan and To Make A Spark.

Reach by ToixStory

This was not very good. I try to be pretty generous when describing stories, mostly since I think about how I’d want someone to talk about my work, but I had to force myself through the last half of this one. I think it can be summed up in, the big bad moustache-twirling ‘bwa ha ha’ villain is the elements of Harmony. The last third of the story is the elements floating around blasting things with magic lasers and ranting about how the pony race needs to be cleansed to make way for a new utopia. Yep. I mean, I’ve read a story that had something similar in it, but that was built up ahead of time and explained in a way to make things all fit together. Plus the elements were more in sorrow than anger, and they were nice, just alien. In this story they are pretty much just flat out evil. None of the story fits together. We have a controlling intelligence service that is everywhere and presented as a controlling authority with black sunglasses and kidnap people at will, yet almost everyone in that organization seems to be nice people in a bad situation. Seriously. Evil organization made up of good ponies just trying to do what they think is best. Oh, and nothing is done to try smoothing out that dissonance. It’s not a ‘system is bigger than anyone’ type thing. It’s just the reader is told one thing and shown another, then shown the first thing and told the second thing. Pretty much whatever the author wanted to do that paragraph. With the ending being a way, way too long pointless fight scene between two gods. The gods yelling at each other while the main characters just sort of stand around until one of the gods sacrifices herself to give one of the characters the deus ex machina power that defeats the bad guy. Yep.

Transistance by ToixStory

Same author as Reach, two stories back. This one is better in that it actually as some logical coherence. It still isn’t what I’d call great. Average. Too many references to Blade Runner. Lots of places those references felt more like a crutch than a homage. Ending was okay. Not a deus ex machina, exactly, but not exactly satisfying either. This really could have used a ‘100 years later’ epilogue to see the ramifications of what happened. One of the basic premises of the story was that Celestia and Luna are always fighting. Apparently they love each other as sisters, but have never had any length of time just working together happily. Which isn’t a really good viewpoint for their characters.

(The Most Inappropriate) Hearthswarming Stories for Foals by Biochi

Another fun, if not exactly light, story. Well, stories anyway. Each one is a interesting bit of worldbuilding. Nothing major. Just little glimpses of the not-so-nice sides of history. As well as the fact that immortal gods might not be the best judge about what kinds of stories should be told to cheer friends up. Worth a read, but don’t think I’ll ever be tempted to read it a second time.

Advertisements
 
3 Comments

Posted by on May 28, 2014 in Books 2014, Ponies, Reviews

 

3 responses to “Pony Stories 142

  1. xjuggernaughtx

    May 29, 2014 at 1:17 pm

    Chris is an all-around good guy. Everyone should be reading his stuff.

     
    • Griffin

      May 29, 2014 at 4:09 pm

      You seem to imply there are people not reading his stuff. Sounds like we need to get a mob together and fix this.

       
      • xjuggernaughtx

        May 29, 2014 at 11:11 pm

        It’s been my experience that an alarming number of people don’t read his stuff, or lots of other good stuff, really. I mean, Wyrmlysan is sitting at less than eight hundred views while the latest Pound and Pumpkin incest fic has something like two thousand views currently. This is definitely mob material in my book. I’m going to get out the good pitchfork for this one.

         

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s