Well, did not get lucky with this batch. I think it was during these that I started pondering just not reading the last dozen or so. I’m a dozen fics past these by the time I’m writing this up, and I think I’m just going to cheat. I’ve got seven stories to go and the previous two I read were not very good so I give up. I’m checking PresentPerfect’s review post to see if any of the final ones are worth reading. So tomorrow’s post will be the last set of stories from the contest, then back to our regularly read horsewords.
This isn’t very good. Actually, it was pretty horrible. I think it’s trying to be an absurd crackfic but the author doesn’t have the skills to pull it off so it just comes off as terribly written instead. I would not recommend this one.
Ha! I review the stories the other reviewers won’t. Here on this blog we review all the stories in the contest. Or, you know, I could say that if I didn’t actually tell the other reviewers where to find it and they already put out their reviews of it. Well, stalled long enough. To the story.
This is very badly written. It is either a parody or a crackfic gone horrible wrong, or someone with english as a third language. I only got halfway through before giving up. I suggest you read TWILIGHT SPARKLE FIXES EVERYTHING instead of this.
Starts a bit cliche, but the ending was interesting. Not in my top ten for the contest, but I’d recommend it. Another story where the human in question focuses on the fact that the ponies have really big eyes. Which seems like an odd thing to put the focus on, that cartoon characters have unaturally large eyes. I mean, that’s like the most realistic thing about the MLP ponies.
Well, this story doesn’t have a dull premise. And now I’m out of nice things to say about it. The author seems to have been trying to be witty and/or clever, but didn’t get anywhere near pulling it off successful. Would not recommend.
A bit simple, but it had an interesting idea at the core of it. If you don’t mind the rough writing and slightly odd first-person perspective, you might give this a try. Certainly gave me some fuel for my headcanon about the discord era of history.
This story earns points for ambition and creativity, just not a lot of them. I’d rate it as decent, but nowhere near great. Gets a bit too meta (sort of) and rough writing quality in general. Still, not a bad read if you can follow it.